Software downloads leads
85 of the 715 BuySellAds sites (12%) are software downloads sites, more than any other niche.
Network ScoutBuySellAds
See which websites run BuySellAds and its Carbon ads, in which niches and at what size, checked against each site's own ads.txt and BuySellAds' sellers.json. Then what Carbon asks of a site in 2026, how its single ad and exclusivity rule work, how BuySellAds pays, and what a visit on it earns.
A publisher ID, a website, an Amazon tag or an analytics ID.
Ranked by our estimate of monthly visits, among the sites where BuySellAds is the only ad network we see, so their display ad revenue is BuySellAds's. The rows behind black bars open with a free account.
| # | Site | Niche | Visits a month | Estimated BuySellAds revenue a month |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gaming | 13M | $8,450 to $52,813 | |
| 2 | Personal finance | 3.3M | $2,574 to $16,088 | |
| 3 | Hidden site: reveal with a free account | Software downloads | ||
| 4 | Software downloads | 3M | $2,730 to $17,063 | |
| 5 | Hidden site: reveal with a free account | Online tools | ||
| 6 | Education | 1.7M | $2,341 to $14,630 | |
| 7 | Hidden site: reveal with a free account | General content | ||
| 8 | Software downloads | 1.4M | $1,274 to $7,963 | |
| 9 | Hidden site: reveal with a free account | Software downloads | ||
| 10 | Hidden site: reveal with a free account | General content |
Revenue is the site's estimated monthly visits × the calculator's rate for its niche, adjusted for its main audience country where our index knows it (Japan and Korea, or no country with half the visits, count as a mix), shown from 0.4 to 2.5 times the middle, since a single site spreads further than the calculator's typical one. Our estimate, not the site's own figure.
What stands out in the latest load. The tables below break each one down.
85 of the 715 BuySellAds sites (12%) are software downloads sites, more than any other niche.
Of the BuySellAds sites whose main audience country we know, 52% write mainly for readers in the United States, the largest single group.
Every BuySellAds site, by the niche our crawler filed it under, with the typical site's monthly visits and what a month of those visits earns at BuySellAds's reported rates.
| Niche | Sites | Share | Typical visits a month | Typical month at BuySellAds rates |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Niche pending | 144 | 20% | 32k | $53 to $72 |
| Software downloads | 85 | 12% | 305k | $590 to $798 |
| Education | 73 | 10% | 75k | $145 to $196 |
| Tech | 63 | 9% | 29k | $64 to $87 |
| General content | 56 | 8% | 190k | $315 to $426 |
| Personal finance | 47 | 7% | 120k | $199 to $269 |
| Online tools | 34 | 5% | 175k | $338 to $458 |
| Business & marketing | 33 | 5% | 97.5k | $162 to $219 |
| Gaming | 29 | 4% | 150k | $207 to $280 |
| News & politics | 24 | 3% | 260k | $287 to $389 |
| Entertainment | 22 | 3% | 52.5k | $58 to $78 |
| Generators | 16 | 2% | 160k | $309 to $419 |
| Sports | 13 | 2% | 18k | $30 to $40 |
| Fashion & beauty | 11 | 2% | 200k | $332 to $448 |
| Automotive | 8 | 1% | 7.4k | $12 to $17 |
| Health & fitness | 8 | 1% | 47k | $78 to $105 |
| Travel | 8 | 1% | 36k | $60 to $81 |
| Calculators | 6 | 0.8% | 63k | $122 to $165 |
| Jobs & careers | 6 | 0.8% | 47.5k | $79 to $107 |
| Home & garden | 5 | 0.7% | 97k | $161 to $218 |
| Science & nature | 5 | 0.7% | 32k | $53 to $72 |
| Printables & templates | 4 | 0.6% | 510k | $845 to $1,144 |
| Spirituality | 3 | 0.4% | 320k | $530 to $718 |
| Converters | 2 | 0.3% | 907k | $1,754 to $2,374 |
| Game tools | 2 | 0.3% | 1.3M | $1,740 to $2,353 |
| Parenting & family | 2 | 0.3% | 12.4k | $20 to $28 |
| Real estate | 2 | 0.3% | 7.7k | $13 to $17 |
| Shopping & deals | 2 | 0.3% | 27k | $45 to $61 |
| Food & recipes | 1 | 0.1% | 2k | $3 to $4 |
| Outdoors | 1 | 0.1% | 21k | $35 to $47 |
"Typical" is the median of the sites in that niche we have a traffic estimate for, earning at the calculator's rate for the niche with a mix of countries. "Niche pending" sites are still being labelled.
We have a traffic estimate for 697 of the 715 sites. The typical one gets about 100k visits a month.
For the BuySellAds sites also in our AdSense index, which records each site's main audience country, language and type. Where the readers live moves earnings per visit more than anything else on this page.
327 of the 715 sites (46%) show BuySellAds and no other ad network. The rest most often run it alongside the networks below. Carbon must be the only ad network on a site, but BuySellAds' sponsorships and its Optimize header bidding run beside other demand, so a second network on a BuySellAds site is usually Optimize's programmatic partners or a site that sells sponsorships through BuySellAds and runs display ads elsewhere.
Put in a site's monthly pageviews, its niche, where its readers are and the month, and get the monthly figure a typical BuySellAds site like it earns, within a narrow range. An estimate to plan with, not a quote.
$227 to $307a month
About $267 from 66,667 visits, at $4.00 per 1,000 visits.
Carbon publishes a typical range of $1.50 to $2.30 per 1,000 ad impressions, one ad to a page, and no earnings by niche, so the rates are our synthesis: the top of that range for US, UK, Canadian and European readers, less pages that serve no ad, put per visit at 2 pages a visit and spread by how closely each niche matches Carbon's developer advertisers. The range is the middle figure ±15%: a typical site with these inputs, while single sites can land further out. What a visit earns explains each setting.
What BuySellAds is, what it asks of publishers in 2026, how it pays, what publishers say about it and what a visit on it earns, each fact linked to its source. About 16 minutes to read.
BuySellAds is a US advertising company that sells ad space on sites, newsletters and podcasts read by developers, designers and other technical people. Its best-known product is Carbon, a curated network that shows one small native ad, an image and a line of copy, on each page of a developer or design site. Around it BuySellAds runs Carbon Direct, a sales team that sells sponsorships for larger publications, and Optimize, a managed header-bidding service for sites that want programmatic display ads. The legal company is BuySellAds.com Inc., its terms are governed by Massachusetts law, and its sellers.json gives a Boston postal address.
Its publisher page says "since 2008", and Carbon's pages say BuySellAds has run Carbon since 2010. Carbon now describes itself as a network of 350+ developer and designer websites serving 250 million ad impressions a month, and BuySellAds says it has paid publishers more than $120 million since it began. Some startup databases date Carbon's purchase to December 2013; Carbon's own pages say 2010, and we go by those.
BuySellAds began as a self-serve marketplace where a publisher listed ad slots at a price of its choosing and advertisers bought them, with BuySellAds taking a commission. Reviews still describe it that way, but its publisher page in 2026 offers Carbon, Direct, Optimize and audience reporting, and doesn't mention a marketplace any more.
BuySellAds starts as a marketplace for buying and selling ad slots on blogs.
Carbon starts, run by BuySellAds, with one ad per page on developer and design sites.
BuySellAds buys Fusion Ads, another one-ad-per-page network for creative sites, and Beacon Ads.
BuySellAds buys LaunchBit, an ad startup for software businesses.
BuySellAds takes a majority stake in Digg, the social news site.
Drupal.org pilots Carbon as a closed, developer-only ad exchange that sets no tracking cookies.
Trade press reports BuySellAds owns Digg and Pando and uses them to test a publishing platform.
Modrinth, a large open-source game mod site, tests Carbon and returns to EthicalAds within about six weeks.
Carbon earnings start arriving around the 25th of the following month.
Carbon's publisher FAQ is last reviewed, on 25 October.
Carbon is the product most sites on BuySellAds run. After approval the publisher gets its Carbon code, and, if it wants, a version that doesn't track readers. The code loads one ad on the page, in a spot the publisher chooses within Carbon's rules. Advertisers book campaigns at a CPM quoted for each campaign, pay in advance and plan for about three months at a time, so the ads a site shows are mostly developer tools, cloud services and software companies.
A 260x200 image with up to 100 characters of copy: the small box developers know from documentation sidebars.
A larger native unit on selected sites, with a logo, a 500x500 picture and a short call to action. Carbon says it "never pops, autoplays or follows anyone around".
An early-access kit that shows one ad in command-line tools, terminal apps and AI assistants, paid through BuySellAds like a website.
Sponsorships, sponsored content and newsletter or podcast deals, sold by a BuySellAds team for larger publications, with an exclusive management option.
BuySellAds' header bidding inside the site's own Google Ad Manager account, with "50+" demand partners and no lock-in.
Audience insights and campaign reports to help a publication pitch sponsors.
The publisher places the Carbon ad, but Carbon's placement policy sets the limits. On desktop the ad must be visible above the fold at 1366x768 or larger; on mobile it must sit within three screen heights of the top, or the site can switch mobile ads off. The code loads once per page, can't be changed or hosted elsewhere, and no part of the ad may be hidden. Ads can't refresh on their own, except on sites that change pages in the browser without reloading. Carbon can add its own CSS to fix display problems without asking.
Carbon's FAQ says plainly that "Carbon is an exclusive network": its ad must be the only ad network on the site, and Carbon can't be used to fill slots other networks leave empty. A site's own promotions are allowed on desktop only as logos or text links. BuySellAds' general terms are non-exclusive, and Optimize says it has no lock-in, so the rule is Carbon's, not every product's.
That is the opposite of most contextual and native networks on our site. Infolinks, Media.net and Taboola all run beside other ads by design. Carbon trades the extra slots for one well-placed ad and advertisers who want a developer audience in a clean setting.
Carbon says "We start at 10,000 pageviews a month", reviews every site by hand and replies within 7 business days either way (Join Carbon, read 13 November 2026).
Traffic is only the first test. Carbon's FAQ calls the network "by invitation only": a site asks for an invitation through a review, and Carbon weighs how relevant its ads are to the audience, the monthly pageviews, whether the site is actively maintained, whether Carbon has room for another publisher, and whether the site can keep to its terms, placement policy and exclusivity.
| Test | What Carbon says |
|---|---|
| Traffic | From 10,000 pageviews a month |
| Audience | English-speaking developers and designers, mainly in the US, Canada and Europe |
| Kind of site | Sites for developers, designers and their communities: docs, tools, tutorials, projects people return to |
| Upkeep | Actively maintained |
| Room | Depends on Carbon's capacity for new publishers at the time |
| Rules | Able to follow the terms, placement policy and exclusivity |
Send the site through Carbon's join form; sites that applied before use the reapply link.
A person reviews the site and Carbon replies within 7 business days, yes or no.
Add the Carbon code, or the no-tracking version, once per page in a spot that meets the policy.
Carbon works with the site on placement to reach the network's 0.07% click-through target.
Carbon Direct and Optimize publish no traffic minimum. BuySellAds' application asks for monthly users, pageviews and subscribers in bands, the smallest being under 100,000 users or under 200,000 pageviews, and qualified applicants are invited to a call. A competitor's guide says BuySellAds recommends 100,000 pageviews; we found no BuySellAds page that says so.
Carbon publishes no list of banned content the way display networks do. Its pages say rejections are "usually fit or timing, not the quality of your work", and that a site can reapply when it changes. In practice that rules out:
Recipe, lifestyle, celebrity or general news sites whose readers aren't developers or designers.
Under 10,000 pageviews a month.
Docs and projects that no longer get updates.
Carbon must be the only network, so a site running AdSense or a header-bidding wrapper must drop it.
Carbon can turn away a good site when it has no advertiser capacity for it.
Advertisers buy English-speaking audiences and can exclude 20+ non-English countries at no cost.
BuySellAds sells four things to publishers, and each has its own rules. The counts on this page cover every site that lists BuySellAds, whichever product it uses.
| Product | What it is | Entry | Exclusive? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carbon Network | One native ad per page, sold to developer advertisers | 10,000 pageviews a month | Yes |
| Carbon Direct | A sales team for sponsorships, sponsored content, newsletters and podcasts | No number; a discovery call | Optional exclusive management |
| Optimize | Managed header bidding in the site's own Google Ad Manager | No number published | No: "remove tags anytime" |
| Carbon CLI | One ad in command-line tools and AI assistants, in early access | An application | Not stated |
Optimize works differently from Carbon. Google pays the site its Ad Exchange earnings directly, after BuySellAds' share, and the Optimize site lists "Net 25 payouts (AdX)". A site on Optimize is earning from a full programmatic stack, not one Carbon ad, so the calculator on this page, which models Carbon, will read low for it.
BuySellAds publishes no revenue share for any of the four products.
The core of Carbon, and the niches that lead our counts above: software, tech, online tools and education.
One ad per page, approved under Acceptable Ads, with a no-tracking option: a fit for open-source projects that dislike ad clutter.
Carbon Direct sells sponsorships, priced per deal rather than per ad impression.
Not Carbon: one ad earns a few dollars per 1,000 pageviews. A managed display network earns more on the same traffic, with more ads.
Each network counts something different for its entry bar, so keep the unit beside the number. Carbon sits near the bottom on traffic but asks for a narrow audience, which no other network in the table does.
| Network | Minimum to join | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Google AdSense | None | - |
| Journey by Mediavine | About 1,000, from the US, UK, Canada and Australia | Sessions in 30 days |
| Carbon (BuySellAds) | 10,000, hand-reviewed, developer and design sites only | Monthly pageviews |
| Monumetric (Propel) | 10,000 to 80,000, half from the US, UK, Canada or Australia, $99 setup fee | Monthly pageviews |
| Raptive | 25,000 since October 2025, half from five countries | Monthly pageviews |
| Mediavine Official | $5,000 since January 2026 | Yearly ad revenue |
| Ezoic | 250,000 since February 2026 | Monthly active users |
| Carbon | EthicalAds | Google AdSense | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum | 10,000 pageviews a month | 50,000 pageviews a month | None |
| Typical earnings | $1.50 to $2.30 per 1,000 ad impressions | About $2.50 per 1,000 pageviews, mostly EU and North American readers | Varies by niche and country |
| Ads per page | One | Not stated on its FAQ | As many as the site places |
| Exclusive | Yes | Not stated; no contract | No |
| Audience | Developers and designers | Developers | Any |
Carbon and EthicalAds land close per page, and a test by one large open-source site found little between them once tracking ads were switched off (see below). AdSense can earn more on the same page with several units, but it doesn't keep the page down to one ad.
For a developer site that has outgrown one ad, the step up is a managed display network, which replaces Carbon rather than sitting beside it. Publift is the network BuySellAds sites most often share in our data, and AdPushup is also common there. Ezoic takes sites from 250,000 monthly users, and Raptive and Mediavine are built for lifestyle blogs more than developer tools. Each pays more per visit than one Carbon ad, at the cost of many more ads on the page.
BuySellAds isn't in the bloggers' income surveys we use on other network pages, so there is no survey average to set beside the others.
Neither Carbon nor BuySellAds states a percentage. Reviews of the old marketplace say BuySellAds took 25% of each sale; we found nothing current for Carbon.
Earnings are visible within 30 days of a month's end and withdrawable within 60. Since 1 September 2026 they arrive around the 25th of the next month.
The account opens automatically on joining; each payout method has its own minimum.
Open-source projects can be paid into Open Collective, quarterly under the current policy (dated March 2026), on request to their account manager.
| Method | Minimum balance | Fee |
|---|---|---|
| PayPal | $20 | PayPal's transaction fees |
| Check | $50 | Not stated |
| Wire transfer, through Bill.com | $500 | $35 |
| Open Collective | Not stated | Open Collective and host fees, by account |
Carbon pays on served impressions only: an ad that a blocker stops or a bot never renders earns nothing, which is why its count is lower than a site's pageviews (Carbon FAQ). Carbon says no rate is guaranteed, and that readers' countries move it most, then click-through and advertiser demand.
BuySellAds' terms let it charge an inactive account $100 a month after six months without activity, and let it withhold or offset money owed to the publisher. Withdraw the balance before you stop.
A summary of what publishers have written in public, not a review of our own. Few publishers share Carbon figures, some reviews come from rival networks, and some carry referral links. We couldn't read Reddit or Facebook groups for this page, so nothing here comes from them.
| Source | Period | Figure |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon's own FAQ | Last reviewed October 2026 | Typically $1.50 to $2.30 per 1,000 ad impressions, no rate guaranteed |
| Modrinth, open-source game mod site, over 4 million pageviews a month | September to October 2022 | Carbon about equal to or below EthicalAds once tracking ads were off; EthicalAds had paid it $0.24 per 1,000 pageviews |
| EthicalAds, for comparison | Undated FAQ | About $2.50 per 1,000 pageviews for mostly EU and North American readers |
We found no dated report from 2024 to 2026 that gives a site's Carbon or BuySellAds earnings beside its traffic. Modrinth's figures are older and from a site whose readers are spread worldwide, so we use them to show direction, not level.
Carbon's CPM is per 1,000 ads served. With one ad per page it's close to a page RPM, but pages with blocked or unloaded ads earn nothing.
A sponsorship or an Optimize stack can earn more per page than one Carbon ad. Ask which product a figure comes from.
Carbon says readers' countries set its rate more than anything else, and advertisers can drop 20+ non-English countries.
Carbon names ad blockers among the reasons its count runs below pageviews. Acceptable Ads approval lets some blockers show Carbon, not all.
Several reviews of BuySellAds are written by rival networks or carry referral links.
Carbon says nothing about seasons. Its campaigns are prepaid for about three months at a time, which smooths the swings auctions show.
Carbon publishes one range, $1.50 to $2.30 per 1,000 ad impressions, and no figures by niche or country. The rates below are our synthesis: the top of that range for readers in the US, UK, Canada and western Europe, cross-checked with EthicalAds' $2.50 per 1,000 pageviews, less pages where no ad loads, and put per 1,000 visits at 2 pages a visit. They model Carbon's one ad, not Direct sponsorships or Optimize.
| Niche | Per 1,000 visits |
|---|---|
| Technology and development | $4 |
| Software, downloads and online tools | $3.50 |
| Education and tutorials | $3.50 |
| Business, marketing and design | $3 |
| Personal finance | $3 |
| Gaming and game tools | $2.50 |
| News and entertainment | $2 |
| Any other niche | $3 |
Development sites lead because Carbon's advertisers are developer tools and cloud companies, and they click more there; Carbon itself says click-through and demand move the rate. Gaming, news and entertainment pages draw wider audiences that those advertisers value less. The spread between niches is our judgement; the level is set by Carbon's range. At these rates a developer site with 50,000 visits a month and mostly US readers would earn about $200 a month from Carbon.
| Readers mostly in | Factor |
|---|---|
| The US, UK, Canada, Australia or western Europe | ×1 |
| A mix of countries | ×0.65 |
| India, Southeast Asia, Latin America or Africa | ×0.35 |
| Month | Factor |
|---|---|
| October to December | ×1.1 |
| An average month | ×1 |
| July | ×0.9 |
| January | ×0.8 |
| The first month on BuySellAds | ×0.85 |
Display auctions usually swing from about 0.75 in January to 1.2 at the end of the year. Carbon sells campaigns months ahead at a quoted price, and developer-tool budgets follow business quarters more than holiday shopping, so we use a smaller swing. The first-month factor allows for the placement work Carbon does with new sites during their first three months.
The calculator shows the middle figure ±15%: what a typical Carbon site with those inputs earns. Single sites spread further, by 30 to 40% even with the same niche, countries and month, mostly because of where the ad sits, how many readers block it and how often they click.
We found no separate Carbon publisher agreement with a notice period. BuySellAds' general terms say:
Removing Carbon means taking its code off the site; Optimize says its tags can be removed at any time. Because Carbon must be the only network, leaving it is also what opens the site to AdSense or a managed network. Few sites in our data have dropped BuySellAds since we began tracking, too few to say where they usually go.
One session on a site, however many pages it views.
An ad styled to sit inside the page's own design; Carbon's image-and-text unit.
Earnings per 1,000 ad impressions; Carbon counts only ads actually served.
Earnings per 1,000 pageviews. See page RPM.
A network that must be the only source of ads on the site, as Carbon is.
An auction where many buyers bid for a site's ad slots at once; BuySellAds' Optimize runs one.
A public file of who may sell a site's ad space. See ads.txt.
A network's public list of the sites it pays. See sellers.json.
Carbon says it starts at 10,000 pageviews a month and reviews every site by hand, replying within 7 business days. It looks for sites for developers and designers, mainly with English-speaking readers in the US, Canada and Europe, that are actively maintained and can follow its placement and exclusivity rules.
Carbon is a network run by BuySellAds since 2010, and payouts go through a BuySellAds account. BuySellAds also sells sponsorships through Carbon Direct and header bidding through Optimize.
Carbon says a typical rate is $1.50 to $2.30 per 1,000 ads served, set mostly by readers' countries, with no rate guaranteed. With one ad per page, a developer site with mostly US readers earns roughly $3 to $4 per 1,000 visits in our estimate.
BuySellAds and Carbon don't publish one. Older reviews of the BuySellAds marketplace say it took a 25% commission on each sale, but we found no current figure for Carbon, Carbon Direct or Optimize.
Earnings are visible within 30 days of a month's end and withdrawable within 60; since September 2026 they arrive around the 25th of the following month. The minimum is $20 by PayPal, $50 by check and $500 by wire, which costs $35.
No. Carbon is an exclusive network: its ad must be the only ad network on the site, and it can't be used to fill slots another network leaves empty. Your own promotions are allowed as logos or text links.
Both show one ad to developers. Carbon asks for 10,000 pageviews a month and is exclusive; EthicalAds asks for 50,000 and says publishers see about $2.50 per 1,000 pageviews from EU and North American readers. One large open-source site that tried both found Carbon no better once tracking ads were off.
Carbon can pause a site that breaks its placement policy, shows no impressions for 14 days, has suspicious traffic, or stays below the network's 0.07% click-through rate after three months of placement help.
No. pubsleuth is an independent research tool and is not affiliated with BuySellAds, Carbon or Google. BuySellAds and Carbon are brands of BuySellAds.com Inc. We read public files to see which sites use which networks.